Gluten-Free Cookie Troubleshooting Guide

Common Cookie Baking Problems:

There are several common cookie-baking problems that I often hear about in my gluten free support group. This seems to be a common thread, so I want to list them out with some causes and fixes:

1. The gluten free cookies are flat.
2. Overly crispy or burnt cookies.
3. Unevenly shaped cookies.
4. The cookies spread.
5. The cookies are sticky.

Flat Cookies:

If your gluten free cookies turned out flat, these are some possible causes of flat cookies.

• This could be due to using too little flour. Measuring your flour accurately is important. Some recipe developers measure the weight of the flour they use. In theory, this is a great idea, but every gluten-free flour blend has a different weight, and dozens of gluten-free flour blends are on the market. Each has a different weight depending on the starch-to-grain ratio of the flour.
• You used a starchy gluten free flour blend. Some starchy blends need more flour because the starch softens when the liquid ingredients are added. This also happens with the Cup4Cup flour blend due to the dried milk powder.
• You used too much butter. This sort of goes hand in hand with using too little flour.
• The cookies were baked at too low of a temperature. Often, oven temperature varies, and it may not be as accurate over time.
• You didn’t chill your cookie dough. This is another biggie. If you use partially melted or softened butter, you must chill your cookie dough.

Flat Cookie Fixes:

To prevent your gluten free cookies from flattening while they bake, I recommend the following:

• Make sure that you measure the ingredients accurately. I recommend using either the spoon or the leveling method to measure your gluten-free flour. Spoon Method: You can also use a spoon to fill the measuring cup. Use a knife to level along the top to remove the extra flour. Leveling Method: Put the measuring scoop into the flour and fill. Do not pack the flour. Use a knife to scrape along the top to remove the extra flour.
• Chill your cookie dough for 30-45 minutes in the refrigerator.
• Try using one of the gluten-free flour blends the recipe creator tested and used successfully.
• Periodically, check your oven temperature to make sure it’s right. Otherwise, the cookies will, for sure, spread if it’s not accurate. You can do this by putting an oven thermometer in the oven. Set the oven to 350º F and see if your oven thermometer reads the same temperature.

The Cookies Spread:

Nothing drives me crazy more than when gluten free cookies spread during baking. This is even worse if you are trying to make cut-out cookies. The main reasons cookies spread are:

• This could be due to using too little gluten free flour.
• Use a gluten-free flour blend with a high starch content or dried milk powder.
• Using too much butter or European butter with a high-fat content can cause spread.
• You used too much sugar.
• You didn’t chill your cookie dough or didn’t chill it long enough.

Spreading Cookies Fixes

To fix this spreading cookies problem, first, you need to identify which problem I listed is the culprit causing your cookies to spread.

• Always measure your ingredients properly. See the above Flat Cookie Fixes for simple directions to measure your gluten free flour.
• If you use a starchy gluten free flour blend or if your blend has dried milk powder (Cup4Cup has this), you must adjust the flour you use. Every gluten free flour blend has a different starch-to-grain ratio. You can tell when you look at the label. Ingredients are listed in the highest quantity to the lowest. I am convinced that blends with dried milk powder need much more flour because the milk powder liquefies when you add the wet ingredients. When possible, try to use the same gluten free flour blend(s) that the recipe creator used and tested.
• If you use too much butter or a European flour blend, you must add more gluten free flour to compensate. (Butter brands like Pluegra and Kerrygold have a higher fat content, which tastes delicious, but it can mess with your dough.)
• Reduce the amount of sugar you use in the recipe. Sugar tends to liquefy when it is heated, and that can make your cookies spread way out.
• Chill your cookie dough. Just wrap it in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30-45 minutes.

Gritty Cookies:

Cookies with a gritty texture are a huge problem in gluten free cookie baking and gluten free baking in general. If you have tried Gluten Free Bisquick, you know exactly what I mean!

The grit is from rice flour, often in the most quantity in gluten free flour blends. The only gluten free flour blend company I know that mills their gluten free flour blends extra fine is Authentic Foods Company. They are the best when it comes to texture.

Gritty Cookie Fix:

The only way I know to eliminate the grittiness is to let your cookie batter sit for 20-30 minutes. This allows the moisture to soften the rice flour.

Crispy or Burnt Cookies:

Crispy and burnt gluten free cookies are an easy problem to fix. This problem is due to three main reasons:

• Baking at too high of a temperature. See the above Flat Cookie Fixes section for instructions to check your oven temperature.
• Leaving the cookies in the oven for too long.
• Your oven rack is too close to the bottom or top of the oven.

Burnt or Crispy Fixes:

To fix this problem, lower the oven temperature or reduce the baking time, and check the cookies frequently while they bake.

You also want to ensure your oven rack is in the middle position. They will burn if the oven rack is too close to the top or bottom burners.

Unevenly Shaped Cookies:

If your cookies are unevenly shaped, this is due to just a couple of simple issues.

First, chill your cookie dough and make sure the dough is chilled evenly. If your dough is not chilled in the middle of the dough ball, parts of your cookies can spread, making them appear uneven.

You also want to ensure you use a flat cookie sheet. Over time, they can become warped, causing uneven heat distribution with that pan.

Sticky Cookies:

If your cookies turn out sticky, they either have too much liquid or were not baked long enough.

Fixing this problem is easy. I recommend adding more flour to the dough and always ensure you bake the cookies for the full recommended time. (Note: oven temperatures can vary wildly. See my note above in the Flat Cookies section about occasionally checking your oven temperature to make sure your oven is accurate.)

My Favorite Gluten Free Flour Blends for Cookies:

Choosing what gluten free flour blend is vital to having success with a recipe. I always recommend using the blend suggested by the recipe creator. If you can’t, I will share that these blends are my go-to blends for cookies. If you need more guidance, I wrote a great gluten free flour guide that will share what flour blends work best in what kind of gluten free baked recipes.

• King Arthur Measure for Measure
• Bob’s Red Mill 1:1
• My DIY Gluten Free Flour Blend (my blend is also gum-free for those sensitive to xanthan or guar gum.)

I have also used GF Jules Flour and Better Batter brand blends. Note that Better Batter is very expensive, so I would recommend waiting for it to go on sale.

How Different Sweeteners Affect Cookie Results:

Different types of sugar can also affect your gluten free cookies in various ways. Here’s how some sugars can affect gluten free cookie baking:

1. Granulated sugar: Granulated sugar is one of my favorite sugar types in cookie baking. Depending on the recipe, I often combine it with brown sugar. Granulated sugar creates a crisp, crunchy texture on the outside of the cookie and a soft, chewy texture on the inside. It also helps the cookie spread because sugar liquefies when baked.
2. Brown sugar: Brown sugar contains molasses, which adds a little caramel flavor to cookies. It also can add moisture, which helps keep the cookie soft and chewy. Cookies made with brown sugar tend to be denser and have a deeper flavor.
3. Powdered sugar: Powdered sugar is very fine and dissolves quickly, which makes it ideal for use in delicate cookies such as my Gluten Free Shortbread. I don’t use powdered sugar in many of my cookie recipes, but I do like to roll cookie dough balls like in these Gluten Free Crinkle Cookies in it before baking. It can produce a soft, tender texture in cookies and help create a smooth surface.
4. Coconut sugar: When using coconut sugar in a cookie recipe, it can be substituted for granulated sugar one-to-one. However, because coconut sugar has a slightly different flavor profile and moisture content, it may affect the texture and flavor of the cookies. This is why I don’t use it as often. If you want to use coconut sugar because you are looking to bake without refined sugars, it is best to experiment with small batches and adjust the recipe as needed. I use coconut sugar to sweeten these Paleo Chocolate Chip Cookies. Also, note that coconut sugar is a darker color than granulated sugar, so it will change the color of your cookies to brown. This may not be a big problem, but if you are making gluten free cut-out cookies, it may not look pretty.
5. Turbinado sugar: I do not use this sugar in my cookie recipes because it doesn’t melt as well and adds too much crunch to cookies. It is a good sugar to roll cookies in, but I wouldn’t recommend it instead of regular sugar.
6. Some people like using honey, maple syrup, and agave nectar instead of sugar. I do not use these, so I can’t offer much guidance on how to use them. Just know that using a liquid will change the dry-to-wet ingredient ratio, and you will probably have to adjust.

My Best Gluten Free Cookie Recipes:

• Gluten Free Toll House Cookies – I tweaked the original Nestle recipe to work better with gluten free flour blends,
• Gluten Free Crumbl Snickerdoodles – This copycat recipe tastes like the real Crumbl Snickerdoodles.
• Gluten Free Brookies – If you can’t decide between making brownies and cookies, this cookie is the best of both.
• Gluten Free Peanut Butter Blossoms – This is for my peanut butter fans.
• Gluten Free Russian Tea Cookies – This popular cookie recipe is great for the holidays.
• Gluten Free Butter Cookies – These yummy cookies taste like those Danish cookies you buy in the blue tin.
• Gluten Free Oatmeal Raisin Cookies – This is a great classic cookie recipe.